Only pressure from below can bring about aTruth, Justice and Reconciliation Commission

It has become increasingly clear since the new DUP led administration was established at Stormont, that there is no political will within the leading political parties of the United Kingdom and Ireland to work towards a Truth, Justice and Reconciliation Commission, that looks at the years of the north of Irelands ‘dirty war’. Including the criminal collusion that we now know took place between UK Security Forces and Irish para-militaries.

For the London based political parties, real scrutiny of the ‘secret state’ has always been out of bounds. At best a Westminster Parliamentary committee will periodically look at the work of the security services. The members of this Committee are more often than not selected due to their longevity as parliamentarians, past links with the military, or worse the very security services they are tasked to investigate. Thus no one is surprised when the members of this committee merely tinker around the edges and offer up a report that give the boys and girls at Spook Central an A Plus.

When you consider that the UK Security Services down the years failed to see the threat the Argentine military posed to the UK Protectorate the Falkland Islands. Allegedly reported wrongly to the British Prime Minister Tony Blair that Saddam Hussein’s regime had WMDs etc; and at one time had as head of the counter-espionage department which worked against the Soviet Union, Kim Philby, who went on to end his career as a KGB General and holder of the Order of Lenin. One might have thought at the very least a little more diligence would have been more appropriate when overseeing the security services. But such is the obscure Byzantine ways of the class ridden British Establishment.

The north of Irelands political parties many of whom represent politically the victims of UK State collusion are little better. The Unionists secretly regard any collusion that tool place as being a necessary price to be paid for defeating and bringing to heel the Provisional Republican Movement. The SDLP is far to timid to go out on a limb over this matter as it is not how they operate, still believing after all that has happened in the north of Ireland that back channels are the way to conduct ‘civilized’ political business when dealing with the UK State.

As to Sinn Fein, whilst I have no doubt the majority of its membership wish to see the British murder machine in Ireland exposed and brought to account, there leaders having signed the GFA, are like a fly caught on an old fashioned fly-paper, believing they have no option but to concede this one to the British State. As they are fearful of what might be revealed about contacts between the security services and leading Republicans if any Commission was to seriously look into the dirty war. When periodically SF leaders fail to restrain themselves due to pressure from below and start making public statements about the need for a collusion enquiry. The British quickly swat them down by retaliating with a leak to some opportunist Unionist politico, who threatens to name some unfortunate Sinner as a long time British security force informer.

So does this mean a Truth, Justice and Reconciliation Commission is dead in the water as many commentators now claim. Not at all, what the aforementioned means is that the responsibility for bringing any TJ@RC into being rests where it always has, with civil society, both in Ireland, the UK, EU and USA. Mr friend Anthony McIntyre is mistaken when he wrote in a recent Blanket article that “It is hard to see how the issue of truth is going to be resolved. The stark answer is that it won’t be. The current British government would need to be of the same mind as the present Argentinean government which has taken a strong stand against the record of the 1976-83 military junta and is demonstrably prepared to grasp the nettle of state murder and torture”.

For what Anthony failed to mention was that previous Argentinean Governments were just as hostile when it came to looking at the dark years of the Military Junta in Argentina as the current British government is to a TJ@RC It was only continuos pressure from Argentine Civil Society that brought about a change in government policy, beginning with the Mothers of the Plaza de Mayo, who three decades ago began their protest in Buenos Aires in support of the victims of the Junta’s dirty war.

Are those who have been the victims of UK State collusion in criminality any less worthy than their Argentine counterparts? Of course not, nor should we underestimate the great reluctance and hostility any campaign for TJ@RC will face from the UK State and its Irish political acolytes. But the struggle for human rights and State accountability have never been easy and has always been paved with a mirage of governmental mantraps and diversions. But by mentioning the Argentine example Anthony has done us a service, for what it shows is solidarity, persistence and bloody mindedness can achieve progress if not tiny miracles. For time and again the Mothers of the Plaza de Mayo were told by the nay-sayers that they could never succeed and were threatened and bullied by the representatives of the State and various political parties who were complicit in the Military Junta’s dirty war. But succeed they did.

We should also not over look the fact that like its Argentinean counterpart, the campaign for a TJ@RC may well take time to achieve its aims and during that period many of the current politicians who are placing road blocks in its path, will gradually be leaving the political scene. Leaving the way open for others, possibly more opened minded and less tainted by the past to take their place and thus it is essential that when this generational change occurs, a strong, vocal TJ@RC Campaign is knocking on their door.

The struggle for a TJ@RC is part of the broader struggle for the United Democratic Socialist Republic. For with the GFA the British State is doing all it can to turn the clock back and rewrite its brutal history in the six counties. An on going campaign to expose the levels of UK collusion in criminality during the long war is necessary to expose those who choose to acquiesce to the revisionist historical viewpoint. There are those who will and do claim that the military occupation of the six counties during the long war was all about enforcing the rule of law. The very presence of an activeTJ@RC campaign and the British State’s refusal to establish such a Commission will tell the world that British claims about being the guardians of the rule of law in Ireland are nothing less than historical hogwash.



Filed under Uncategorized

3 responses to “Only pressure from below can bring about aTruth, Justice and Reconciliation Commission

  1. Anonymous

    mick, i don’t ever see a truth and reconciliation commission ever coming about. A few reasons,mainly there is no appetite for it among the general public,only for those poor families who lost loved ones. Secondly, too much has moved on. the people in this city/province arf more interested in scraping together the money to pay the mortgage than a TJRC. Unfortunately that is so. SF have no ‘interest’ in seeing one,despite paying it lip service, and things will move rapidly now especially if there is an election called soon.. FF have nointerest in it. Basically its a case of no more to see here lets move on….!

  2. Anonymous

    that was me daisy mick, but i couldn’t get it to take my id.

  3. Mick Hall


    What you say is correct and of course people want to get on with their lives, which is a hard enough struggle for most of us at the best of times. But something dreadful happened in the north of Ireland, the State which was tasked to protect its citizens in some cases did the exact opposite, and colluded with those who were to put it bluntly sectarian killers.

    Imo in time many people will come to believe that this was just not on and a majority will come to feel that someone should be made to answer for this collusion. I use the word answer and not pay for good reason, this campaign is not about retribution but understanding what occurred, so that measures can be put in place so that future generations do not again experience what went on during the long war.

    True it appears that the current SF leadership [and other parties] do not have the stomach for this but as I wrote, a TJ@RC will not happen tomorrow and as in Argentina others politicians, less associated with the troubles will take the place of the current SF leadership due to generational changes, and these people may well understand that in a democracy a crime is a crime even if it is servants of the State who commit it; and to just brush such crimes under the carpet is a very dangerous and foolish way for any society to behave.

    Best regards

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s